DepthReading
The Momumental Work of the Chinese Scholarship on the Silk Road: an Review of Huang Wenbi’s Xiyu shidi kaogu lunji/The Analects of the Archaeology of the History and Geography of the Western Regions
The Momumental Work of the Chinese Scholarship on the Silk Road: an Review
of Huang Wenbi’s Xiyu shidi kaogu lunji/The
Analects of the Archaeology of the History and Geography of the Western Regions
Huang Wenbi
(1893-1966) is the renowned archaeologist and historial geographer of the
twentieth century. He participated in the China-Sweden joint Scientific Mission
to North-Western China in 1927 as the only Chinese archaeologist. The first
trip set out on May 9th, 1927, marks the start of the over three
years trip of the investigation in Mongolia and Xinjiang, as well as his
life-long journey of the study of the North-Western China.
The Commercial
Press published the selected works of Huang Wenbi under the titled “Xiyu shidi
kaogu lunji,” and selected the book into “The series of the Modern Classics of
the Chinese Academy.” This selected anthology highlights the unique methodologies
applied by Huang Wenbi on the investigation and research of the North-Western
China, including the equal attention paid by him to multiple disciplines such
as archaeology, history, and geography, and his dynamic integration of the
investigation of specific sites in the North-Western with the evaluation of the
regional features of the Silk Road area. Emphasizing the importance of
archaeological physical evidences, his research on the historial geography of
the North-Western region broke through the limitation of the one-sided emphasis
on literature evidences in the Qing scholarship. His case-by-case study of the
archaeological sites well applied the “dual-evidence” methodology by quoting
literary evidences from the descendant classic works.
Through his
four investigations at Xinjiang, Huang Wenbi has traveled over 38000
kilometres, investigated over hundreds of sites, and excavated dozens of them
with specific focuses. He kept records of all these sites with details at
different levels. Therefore, he is worthy of the title of the initiator of the
Chinese archaeological study of Xinjiang, whether talking about how early his
work was, how long he has worked on the archaeological research of Xinjiang and
the historial geographical study of the North-Western region, or how wide,
deep, and the fruitful that his investigations were.
The rich field
work experience achieved by Huang Wenbi at Mongolia during the first
investigation and the following trips to sites such as Qin Great wall, Heliutu,
and Juyanbu has provided him abundant archaeologial materials for the further study
of the historial geography of the Northern region. After arriving at Xinjiang,
Huang Wenbi completed the first scientific archaeological investigation and
excavation at Xinjiang by himself in the Turfan Basin, Taklamakan Desert, and
Lop Nor. It was this excavation that laid the foundation for the publication
about Gaochang potteries and Turfan epigraphs, and the discoveries of the site
of Tuyin and the southern and northern rivers. The second expedition to
Mongolia and Xinjiang was taken place from 1933 to 1934. Starting from 1943,
the third expedition to Xinjiang was commissioned by the Northwestern
University. In 1957, at his age of 64, Huang Wenbi led the archaeological team
to Xinjiang after the founding of the new China. This was the fourth, as well
as the last expedition to the Western region of his life.
The early
publications of Huang Wenbi focused on the archaeological discoveries at the
Turfan Basin, including Gaochang
zhuanji/The Collection of Bricks of Gaochang (1931) and Gaochang taoji/The Collection of Pottery of
Gaochang (1933). These works were highly recommended by a group of leading
scholars including Xiang Da and Zheng Shixu in less than one year after their publications.
Xiang Da said that “Huang’s work had the highest accomplishment among the
Chinese publications about the discovery of the Scientific Mission to
North-Western China. Zheng Shixu said that “his research neither followed
blindly the idea that considered the Han people to be descendents of the West,
nor overstated that Chinese culture was above all.”
Using his own
system of classification, Huang Wenbi contributed excellently to the study of
potteries, brick epigraphs, and manuscripts of Turfan in Gaochang zhuanji/The Collection of Bricks of Gaochang (Revised and
Enlarged) published in 1951 and Tulufan
kaogu ji/The Turfan Archaeological Record in 1954. His research represented
in Gaochang jiangyu juncheng kao/The
Interpretation of the Territory and Prefecture of Gaochang, Gaochang guo guanzhi biao/The Official
System of Gaochang, Gaochang guo
Qushi jinian/The Chronology of the Qu Family of Gaochang, Ningshuo jiangjun Qu Bin zaosibei jiaoji/The
Emending Excursus of the Ningshuo General Qu Bin’s Stele of the Establishment
of an Temple, and Zhang Huaiji muzhiming
jiaoji/The Emending Excursus of the Epigraph of Zhang Huaiji laid
foundation for the further study of the history of Gaochang. From the 30’s to
the 50’s of the twentieth century, Huang Wenbi’s scholarship has been tracked
and studied by a series of renowned Japanese scholars of the history of the
Western Regions, such as Mizuno Seiichi, Fujieda Akira, Ishida Mikinosuke, and
so on. For instance, Mizuno Seiichi said that “it should be celebrated the
Chinese archaeology began to adopt the scientific method that should have been
used,” as a response to contribution made by Huang Wenbi in his Gaochang taoji/The Collection of Pottery of
Gaochang, which broke the limitation of the traditional Chinese study of
implements by adopting the scientific methods.
Luobuzhuoer kaogu ji/The Archaeological
Record of Lop Nor is the representative of the first wave of publications
on the research of Lop Nor taken by Chinese scholars. Huang Wenbi contributed
to the field primarily on the discovery and research of the Tuyin site and
Juyan bamboo slips of the Han Dynasty found there, the ancient route at the
northern bank of the Peacock River and other surrounding sites. Tuyin bamboo
slip was the earliest and largest excavation of the Western Han slips of
Xinjiang. It was on the base of this excavation and the slips found that Huang
Wenbi achieved some new insights on the study of the bureaucratic system,
transportation, and storage during Western Han’s governing of the Western
Region. Thus, the Tuyin site was considered as the second most significant
excavation at the area of Lob Nor after the discovery of the ancient city ruins
at Loulan. The distinction of the culture between the southern and the northern
bank of the Peacock River is significant to the study of the changes of the
Peacock riverway and the site of Loulan.
Talimu pendi kaogu ji/The Archaeological
Record of the Tarim Basin further highlighted Huang Wenbi’s contribution to
the research of the oasis city sites spread around the Tarim Basin at Xinjiang.
He left his footprints at Yanqi, Korla, Luntai, Kucha, Xayar, Baiceng, Khotan, Yutian,
Pishan, Karghalik, Bachu, Kashgar, and Aksu. He focused on the study of the riverways
and historic sites of the desert hinterland during the trip starting from Shaya
and passing through the Taklamakan Desert to Yutian. Combining his advantage in
the study of the classical documents and evidences collected from the field
work, Huang Wenbi gave full play of the “dual-evidence” methodology in the
study of the ruined capital cities and historic sites of Karasahr, Kucha, and
Khotan. Huang Wenbi’s last archaeological report is Xinjiang kaogu fajue baogao (1957-1958)/The Archaeological Report of Excavations at
Xinjiang (1957-1958) has been
completed before he passed away, and was edited and published by Meng Fanren.
Category: English
DepthReading
Key words: